The Daring Cooks’ Challenges 05/10: Chicken Enchiladas with Homemade Enchilada Sauce

Our hosts this month, Barbara of Barbara Bakes and Bunnee of Anna+Food have chosen a delicious Stacked Green Chile & Grilled Chicken Enchilada recipe in celebration of Cinco de Mayo! The recipe, featuring a homemade enchilada sauce was found on and written by Robb Walsh. You can find the challenge here. Thanks a lot, Barbara and Bunnee, for a fantastic challenge!

I was absolutely thrilled when I learned what the challenge was going to be this month. Mexican food! I LOVE Mexican food. I was in culinary heaven during my vacation in Mexico 10 years ago. When we were back in Germany we tried to find Mexican restaurants that would serve the same food as we had in Mexico, but as usually is the case something was always wrong. I think Mexicans wouldn’t even label German Mexican food Mexican. Same goes for Chinese. I don’t think that Chinese people from China would recognize Chinese food that is served in Germany. Same goes for Italian, Indian, Thai food etc. Is it the lack of certain ingredients? Or is it that restaurant owners that usually ARE Chinese, Mexican, Indian, Italian or Thai have to adapt the traditional food to German tastebuds because otherwise only a few people would eat it? I have no idea… I just know that Italian restaurants in the U.S. are totally different from the ones in Germany, same goes for Indian and Mexican restaurants. And something else I know for sure is that German labeled restaurants in the U.S. do NOT serve German food (maybe Bavarian, but not German – I’m a Prussian, and Prussians hate Bavarians and vice versa, so if you want to be my friend, please don’t label Bavarian stuff German ;-)).

Back to the challenge: I read through the ingredient list and knew I wasn’t able to truly participate. Fresh Anaheim Chiles? Tomatillos? Monterey Jack or Mexican Cheeses? Masa Harina for the corn tortillas? Jeez! Where would I get all these things? No chance finding fresh chiles except for peperoncini. No chance finding Mexican cheese. BUT I found an online source for tomatillos (canned, though) and masa harina.

I didn’t see a chance to follow the given recipe so I searched the internet and my cookbooks and got inspired by one of Mark Bittman’s recipes: Green Enchilada Sauce with Tomatillos. The recipe calls for 2 poblano or other mild fresh green chiles and 2 serrano or other hot fresh green chiles, but I figured green peperoncini are milder than red ones, so I got 2 green peperoncini and 2 red peperoncini, roasted them under the broiler in my oven, peeled and cored them and made the enchilada sauce. I really had to force myself to stop trying it – the salsa was sooooo good.

Also that day, I made corn tortillas and more or less used the recipe given in the challenge (for details, see the bottom of this post). I wish I had bought a tortilla press (which also was available at that online store I got the tomatillos and masa harina from) because shaping them was really annoying. They wouldn’t turn out round at all, but I thought I’d roll them up anyway, so nobody would care.

The next day, I fried some diced chicken breast which I had marinated in lime juice, onions, chile flakes, fresh cilantro, salt and pepper before. Then I filled a casserole dish with half of the enchilada sauce, filled the corn tortillas with the chicken and some mozarella cheese, rolled them up, put them on top of the sauce, and topped the tortillas with the rest of the enchilada sauce and some more mozarella cheese. Into the oven it went for about 25 minutes. I could hardly wait to take it out and try it. WHAT AN AWESOME DISH!

I knew it would be too spicy for my kids so I had filled an additional casserole dish with store bought mild taco sauce (I didn’t feel like making another sauce), and this was a big hit with my kids.

I’ll definitely save the recipes for future reference because this is a dish I’ll make often from now on. I have no idea if it tastes authentically Mexican, but there was something in the enchilada sauce which I couldn’t identify that reminded me of the food we had in Mexico – and it can be the fresh cilantro or the tomatillos only, because I’ve never had those here before.

Green Enchilada Salsa

(adapted from “How to Cook Everything” by Mark Bittman)

makes about 2 cups


  • 28 oz canned tomatillos, finely chopped
  • 2 mild green chile peppers
  • 2 hot red chile peppers
  • 3 tblsp neutral oil
  • 2 large onions, diced
  • 5 cloves garlic, minced
  • 1 tsp oregano
  • 1 cup vegetable stock (I had some in the freezer, made after another Bittman recipe)
  • salt and freshly ground black pepper
  • 1/2 cup chopped fresh cilantro leaves
  • 1/4 cup lime juice


  1. Turn on the broiler and put the rack about 4 inches from the heat source. Put the chile peppers on a baking sheet lined with aluminium foil and broil, turning the peppers as each side browns, until they have darkened and collapsed, 10 – 15 minutes. Wrap the peppers in the foil that lined the pan and cool until you can handle them, then remove the skin, seeds and stems. Chop the chile peppers.
  2. Put the oil in a large deep skillet over medium heat. Add the onions and garlic and cook, stirring occasionally, until they are very soft and lightly browned, about 10 minutes.
  3. Add the tomatillos, chiles, oregano, stock, and a large pinch of salt and pepper; stir and bring to a low simmer. Cook, stirring occasionally, until the mixture thickens slightly, 10 – 15 minutes.
  4. Stir in the cilantro and lime juice, taste and adjust the seasonings.
  5. Use an immersion blender to purée the finished sauce in the pan.

Corn Tortillas

(adapted from Rick Bayless’s Mexican Kitchen)

Makes 15


  • 1 3/4 cups masa harina
  • 1 cup plus 2 tblsp hot water


  1. Pour hot water over masa harina, cover and let sit 30 minutes. Add (additional) cool water 1 tablespoon at a time until the dough is soft but not sticky. Divide the dough into 15 balls and cover with plastic wrap.
  2. Heat a skillet on medium-high.
  3. Put a ball of dough between two sheets of plastic. If you don’t have a tortilla press, roll out to a 5-6” circle using a rolling pin. Put the tortilla into the pan, flip it after about 1 minute and cook for another 1 minute.  Remove from heat and let them rest while cooking the remaining tortillas.

Cilantro & Lime Chicken

(adapted from “How to Cook Everything” by Mark Bittman)


  • 1 lb chicken breast, diced
  • 3 tblsp oil
  • 2 tblsp chopped fresh cilantro
  • 1 tblsp lime juice
  • 1 tblsp chopped onion
  • 1/4 tsp chile flakes
  • salt and pepper


  1. Combine everything in a casserole dish and marinate for 30 minutes
  2. Pour mixture into a skillet and fry until chicken is cooked.

Chicken Enchiladas


  • 2 recipes Green Enchilada Salsa
  • 1 recipe Corn Tortillas
  • 1 recipe Cilantro & Lime Chicken
  • 8 oz Mozarella cheese


  1. Preheat oven to 350°F.
  2. Pour half of the enchilada salsa into a big casserole dish.
  3. Fill the tortillas with chicken pieces and mozarella, roll tightly, and put them in the prepared dish, seam side down. The rolls should be packed in snugly against one another.
  4. Cover the top with the remaining sauce and cheese and bake for 25 minutes.

24 responses to “The Daring Cooks’ Challenges 05/10: Chicken Enchiladas with Homemade Enchilada Sauce

  1. Pingback: Tweets that mention The Daring Cooks’ Challenges 05/10: Chicken Enchiladas with Homemade Enchilada Sauce « Family & Food & Other Things --

  2. Considering that you thought you weren’t going to be able to “truly” participate, it sounds like you did an awesome job!! The cilantro lime chicken sounds delicious, and your green chile sauce sounds great! And your tortillas came out VERY round, considering you shaped them by hand! Awesome job with the challenge!

  3. You did a great job with this challenge. Everything looks so delicious.

  4. I love the composite picture – it really shows the whole process. I’m glad you had fun with the challenge and enjoyed the final product.

  5. I think you did an amazing job finding a great substitute. Sounds just tasty to bits.

  6. love what you did with this months challenge.
    Und wenn ich nicht ein so geiziger schwabe wäre hätte ich mich auch versucht am online kaufen.
    leider aber ist auch die Haushaltskasse schwäbisch und so werde ich eben meine Tomatillopflänzchen für den Sommer pflegen.
    Die Samen habe ich im letzem Jahr geschenkt bekommen ( wurden Online gekauft) und da die guten Tomatillos in england wachesen hoffe ich das klappt auch hier.

  7. I think that authentic taste was due to the masa flour you used that really does add that true Mexican taste to the dish and great to hear that you you went to an on-line store to get the some of the ingredients extra special and it seems all the hard work really paid off in the end. Delicious looking results. Cheers from Audax in Sydney Australia.

  8. Great job! I love the pic at the top!

  9. You really went the extra distance to source the ingredients – it’s great that your hard work paid off. I love the photo montage, and the finished dish looks delicious! By the way, I think your tortillas look great – the handmade ones always have slightly ragged edges, which is part of their charm (though we cheated with ours and trimmed them into circles after rolling them out!)

  10. Your recipe looks fabulous! I’ll be travelling to Berlin sometime this summer, and I’ll have to check out that store and bring and extra suitcase for all the goodies! Thank you for mentioning it.

    I hear you on the Asian food too! I haven’t I have managed to find authentic pizza here in Jena, but it wasn’t easy. My guess is that food is adapted to the German taste buds, but it’s only a guess.

  11. They look great! I think the cilantro lime chicken sounds delicious. I still have a bit of the sauce left so I may have to try your chicken marinade with it. Nice work!

  12. I’m glad you were able to find the ingredients to make some enchiladas. Even better that everyone loved them! For your corn tortillas, press them rather than rolling them to get a round shape. Put a small ball between plastic wrap and use the bottom of a pot. Round tortillas, every time!

  13. I think it’s great that you were so resourceful with the ingredients. In my opinion, I think it’s the water that contributes to the difference — at least, that’s my best guess! I love New Mexico mexican flavors the best, but if restaurants try to recreate the New Mexican flavors, they just fall flat. So, it’s either the water or perhaps the altitude. This green sauce tasted pretty close to authentic.

  14. I almost bought a tortilla press, myself. I ended up laying my large cutting board on the floor, then using my stool to stomp them flat between the layers of ziplock plastic. What a pain… and a huge ordeal. 😉

    Strange notice about eating food in Germany. I’ve never been there, but I remember eating Chinese in Paris once, and I thought it was more authentic than most of what’s available in Seattle. Perhaps you can find the one in a million there, too? 😀 I enjoyed reading your post – and now it’s got me wondering. 🙂

    Thanks for the Bittman recipe, too. Looks like a great out-of-season recipe alternative for me! 😀

  15. I love the tortillas! You really did a great job with the substitutions and your enchiladas look delicious!

  16. Oooh wow what a great job you did on this challenge, I love chicken enchilladas theyre so deliciously tasty!

  17. I’d say you participated in full; your enchiladas look awesome, and the sauce you made sounds great!

  18. Your step-by-step pictures are so nice, congratulations for making your own tortillas 🙂

  19. Your finished dish looks yummy!

  20. Those homemade corn tortillas look a’maze’ing and your enchiladas filled with cilantro lime chicken sound incredible! Love the collage of each step. Mine never look as good when I add more than 4 photos.

  21. You did a great job! Now that’s a cooking challenge right there. You even did a better than i did..i used a store bought corn tortillas=;(

  22. Nice work. Glad you were able to find a taste of your Mexico vacation. When I am missing a place, I cook food from there.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s